So George Michael is currently carting John Lennon’s old piano round America, placing it in scenes of historic violence, in a kind of symbolic pacifist road trip. The piano in question is the one on which Lennon wrote Imagine. Locations visited so far include the Ford’s Theatre in Washington, where Abraham Lincoln was assassinated, and the Lorraine motel in Memphis, site of Martin Luther King’s death. A trip to Auschwitz is planned for later in the year.
Is anyone else utterly baffled by this? Apparently at each stop on the tour the piano has been attracting large crowds. What do they do once they get there, other than mill around thinking, ‘Hmmm, peace…’?
"By taking the piano to all these sites, we are reminded that violence has long been a part of our history," Michael said. Well, yes… but we kind of already knew that. It doesn’t take a piano to convince us that violence is wrong. And isn’t the idea of hauling a £1.5 million piece of rock memorabilia up to the gates of Auschwitz just ever so slightly distasteful?
Perhaps it all depends on your opinion of Imagine itself. To many it’s a universal hymn to peace and brotherhood. Others regard it as a rather mawkish song, whose sentiments wouldn’t sound out of a place on a Hallmark greetings card. One might also question whether the notion of such a fabulously wealthy man imagining “no possessions” isn’t somewhat laughable. And wasn’t it always alleged that Lennon gave financial support to the IRA - a rumour that, if true, would rather sully his reputation as a pacifist?
Perhaps we’re being needlessly cynical – but there’s something maddeningly woolly-minded about a rock artefact being used as a substitute for genuine political debate. Surely it would be better to protest against the root causes of violence today, rather than indulging in lazy historical tourism? Or maybe George Michael should just lay off the weed and start writing decent songs again. Imagine that.
3:12 PM | 17/04/2007
Latest News
-
Bee Gees' Robin Gibb RIP (round-up) Muse carry Olympic torch, Mick Jagger plays with Foo Fighters & Arcade Fire, Jack White new record attempt, Citizens session, Crowded House drummer dies... Daily Hot List
A round-up of all the news, views, interviews and cool music things online today (21 May)
-
Column - Robin's Reign: the remarkable career of the Bee Gees' Robin Gibb
Following the Bee Gee's death last night, Dorian Lynskey looks back at the singer and songwriter's multifaceted work
-
The Cult: 'Nirvana's arrival was like a nuclear bomb for rock bands' - Q311 extract
As the band release a new album today (21 May) they recall how Kurt Cobain and co made them split the first time - get our current issue for the full interview
-
Q's Week that was... Gaz Coombes, sports star who can sing, Great Escape, Donna Summer RIP, T In The Park, Zulu Winter, Niki & Dove & more
Here's what we've been up to this week...
-
Column - How Donna Summer helped change dance music forever
Following her death yesterday (17 May), Paul McGee looks at the Queen Of Disco's creative legacy
-
Donna Summer RIP, Black Sabbath respond to drummer quitting, Van Halen 'hate each other', Adele wins Ivor Novello award, Charlatans vs Wu-Tang... Daily Hot List
A round-up of all the news, views, interviews and cool music things online today (18 May)
Advertisement
User Comments
Post A Comment
Interesting....BTW it was Paul who gave money to the IRA, but you might as well encourage rumours in your pieece. Which makes me wonder who the 'we' is in this story? Are you anti-George Michael, or anti- John Lennon or anti-peace or just anti anti ?
Imagine has long been called naive by some, but we're dreamers and anything can happen in dreams. Everything starts with a dream. I'll dream of peace, thanks anyway. your story is just depressing and status quo. You just don't get it. (George Michael never wrote good songs anyway).
Posted by David Holmes at 9:37 PM | 17/04/2007 | Report Abuse
George Michael never wrote good songs? That's an outrage. 'I Want Your Sex' is twice the song Imagine ever was.
Posted by chazbaps at 4:48 PM | 18/04/2007 | Report Abuse
ones dead and the other one will be soon, lets leave it there.
Posted by badger legs at 9:00 PM | 18/04/2007 | Report Abuse
Being in OKC at the time of the bombing and now still it is kinda strange that a piano is on "tour" sounds like someone has more money than sense, eh? It is almost disrespectful. however where exactly are they gonna put it next the reflecting pool or next to the Survivor Tree?
Posted by Nicole at 9:51 PM | 19/04/2007 | Report Abuse
being in OKC at hte time of the murrah building bombing and still living here, it is kinda strange that they would be taking a piano on tour. sounds like george michael has more money than sense. BTW where exactly are they gonna put it by the Survivor Tree or the reflecting pool?
Posted by Nicole at 9:53 PM | 19/04/2007 | Report Abuse
Post A Comment